Auto Icon


We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Home Icon


We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Business & Commercial Icon

Business & Commercial

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Life Icon


We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Motorcycle Icon


We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Boat Icon


We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Home » 8 Ways the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quote Can Cost You
June 16, 2022

8 Ways the Cheapest Auto Insurance Quote Can Cost You

 a blue truck parked in a parking lot


8 Ways The Cheapest Auto Insurance Quote Can Cost You


No one ever wants to buy insurance, but we all need it.  It’s a necessary evil.  And due to the latest shopping trends of low price discounters like Wal-mart, Aldi, Old Navy, etc. everyone’s trying to find the lowest price possible.  It’s not about quality, it’s about price.  This can become a problem when it comes to insurance.  When people come into or call my office and ask me for the lowest possible price, I give it to them, while still ensuring they have quality coverage.  I want to give them the quality at a price that they can afford.  When buying auto insurance, if your focus is on the cheapest bare minimum coverage, I caution you! You may lose out.  It may cost you in the long run and here are some reasons why: 


1. Not enough liability to cover your assets

Most of the time the cheapest auto policies will give you the lowest possible liability limits allowed by law.  That means you are probably getting the state minimum liability coverage of $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident.  Prior to July 2, 2020 if you cause an accident and someone was injuried, you could only be sued for someone pain and suffering. But now with the new auto laws, you can be sued for someone’s medical expenses along with their pain and suffering.  This can be a problem if you own a home, have a job, have investments and/or have accumulated some wealth.  If you are sued due to an auto accident $50,000 isn’t going to go very far and the next place to look to recoup the money is with your assets.  Meaning, you could lose your home, investments, income, etc.  When discussing your liability limits with your agent don’t go with the lowest, but rather tally up the value of your assets (home, auto, income, investments, etc) and use that figure.  You’d be surprised by how inexpensive it can be to have higher liability limits.


2. Not enough or no PIP for your situation

Since July 2 2020, it is no longer mandatory to have unlimited PIP.  There are now 5 options to choose from. Unlimited, $500,000, $250,000, $50,000 (medicaid only) or complete Opt out (for Medicare and Qualified Heath coverage)  Unlimited is still the best option for most, but may not always be the case.  Cheap auto insurance will have you sign off on the coverage to opt out, lower your premium, but not protect you at all if you are injured in an auto accident.  Health insurance has limits, restrictions, co-pays and deductibles.  Just because you have health insurance, opting out may not be the best option for you.  IF you have questions or need some more information on PIP is a great resource. 


3. No towing or rental reimbursement

Another thing that comes with cheapest auto insurance is that you probably won’t have coverage that you may actually need, like towing or rental reimbursement.  You may think that you are doing yourself a favor but in my experience when something happens people usually don’t want to pay for a tow themselves or in the case of an accident, pay for a rental car.  Think about it this way: if you are in an accident and your car is in the shop for a week, how are you going to get to work?  How are you going to get the kids to school?  A rental may be needed to get back and forth until your vehicle is fixed.


4. No personal service

Contrary to belief, affordable auto insurance isnt alwayed purchased online by the consumer.  The belief that you save money buy not going through an agent is a myth.  When buying online, you are buying it as an individual without the help of a knowledgable agent.  Alot of people have no clue what they just purchased and when it comes claim time, they are left feeling disappointed.  Without an agent you also lose personal service; who are you going to talk to if you have a question, or you need to make a change?  What do you do if you need to file a claim?  More than likely you will have to deal with a call center at a 1-800 number. When you have a problem with your personal belongings the last thing you want is to be just another account number to these internet insurance companies.  




5. Not enough coverage for you and your passengers

Some people will try to cut costs by skipping out on uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage.  Don’t do it.  This coverage is for you, and is only cost about $10.00.  Uninsured motorist covers you in the event that you are injured by an uninsured driver or are injured due to a hit and run.  And there are more and more people out there that are driving without auto insurance so the likelihood of this is higher than it has ever been before.  Underinsured motorist covers you if the other driver doesn’t have enough insurance to pay out on the claim.     



6. No rental loss of use

If you ever rent a car for vacation, work or any other reasons, make sure that your current carriers’ coverage will carry over to the rental vehicle.   Most do, but if you have the bare minimum, cheapest policy then chances are it doesn’t and then you will not need to purchase the expensive additional auto insurance from the rental company.  



7. No glass repair waiver 

Most insurance companies will waive your comprehensive deductible if you are in need a windshield chip repair but some of the cheap companies will require you to pay your deductible first, which is usually $100-$250.


8.  No multi policy discount

Alot of companies claim to have the cheapest auto rates.  But many of these companies fail to mention that you are losing out on your homeowners insurance rate because they don’t offer that coverage. Thus you aren’t getting a multi-policy discount and may pay more for your homeowners insurance.  


Your cheap insurance quote may look good today, but remember when it comes to your insurance you get what you pay for.  Don’t find yourself short changed when you need it most.  At EW Smith Agency, we can find your great coverage at an incredible price.  We know insurance can be complex, let us manage it,  so you don’t have too.


Click this link if you if like a quote. 



a man smiling for the cameraMatthew Perry is an agent and partner at EW Smith Insurance Agency in Wyandotte, Mi. They are an independent agency offering home, auto, life and business insurance. He can be reach at 734.284.414

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

©2024. All rights reserved. | Powered by Zywave Websites